Question 1

The Crump Theatre

Accepted Answer

425 3rd St. Columbus, IN 47201According to Rovene Quigley, executive director of the Crump Theatre, she is never alone in the 1800s building. Many stories exist about this historic theatre including Quigley finding an extra $86.50 in her receipt box and a helpful ghost finding a boiler inspection certificate and placing it on her desk.Visitors see orbs, mists and apparitions in this theatre. Temperature drops and spikes occur preceding these events. EVPs caught in the building include men and women’s voices. Some topics of conversation include “That was fun.”, “What was that?”, “I wish they’d leave.”, and “What are they doing?”

Question 2

Old Railroad Bridge

Accepted Answer

Go into park at the end of 17th St. Walk the path leading into the woods. You will see a tunnel that goes under the tracks with a steep gravel incline. Climb to the top of the tracks and the bridge will be to your right.A woman in the 1920s had an illegitimate child and was driven to throw herself and her child off the bridge. They found her body but not the baby’s body. A creature with two legs and yellow eyes haunts the bridge and sometimes the baby cries. During a full moon the mother of the baby appears and she calls out to her baby. You also hear footsteps.

Question 3

Columbus North High School

Accepted Answer

1400 25th St. Columbus, IN 47201A child named “Mikey” was run down by a buggy on a road that used to be where the school is now. The auditorium is believed to be exactly where he was killed. Mikey runs on the stage, in the sound booth and up on the catwalk. He also turns lights on and off.

Question 4

Quality Machine and Tool

Accepted Answer

1201 Michigan Ave.An employee hung himself over a woman. His shadow figure is seen as well as other spirits. Employees find things missing and returned to odd places.

Question 5

The Haunted House on 7th Street

Accepted Answer

630 7th StreetKnown in the late 1800s and early 1900s as “The Haunted House on 7th Street” after paranormal activity began in the boarding house believed to be caused by the death of a daughter of E.H. Kinney who fell into the coal grate and burned to death around 1880, as well as in 1893 when Ralph Drake shot his mistress and tried to kill himself.

Question 6

1882 Boston Mediums Séance at Schwartzkopf Opera House

Accepted Answer

Jackson St. – Between 2nd & 3rd Streets.

Question 7

1908 Séance at Crump’s Theatre by C.M. Sawyer and Co.

Accepted Answer

425 3rd Street

Question 8

White Star Meat Market/Bespoke Events & Experiences

Accepted Answer

410-412 Washington St.Employees have heard banging from the second floor and had items go missing overnight. The spirit is believed to be John F. Wright M.D. who built the building and had his practice on the second floor. There have also been several sudden deaths in the building.

Question 9

Subway Restaurant on 46

Accepted Answer

1130 25th St.Shadow figures walk through store. Patrons and employees hear voices when no one else is around.

Question 10

Haunted House

Accepted Answer

Second house on right past Huffman Rd on SR 11 (Jonesville Rd.) Address unknown.Strange noises, metallic clangs heard through out home, especially on first floor. Whispers from male and female voices.

Question 11

Ceraland Recreation Area

Accepted Answer

Off 525 E. South of SR46 and north of SR 7.In the 1970s a woman drowned while crossing the creek during a flood. You can see and hear her crying on the edge of the banks.

Bartholomew County Ghost & UFO Stories

Ghost Stories & UFO Sightings